Difference between revisions of "Applets:Binomial and Poisson Distribution (Applet)"
From LNTwww
| (27 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | {{LntAppletLinkEn|binomPoissonDistributions_en}} [https://www.lntwww.de/Applets:Binomial-_und_Poissonverteilung_(Applet) '''English Applet with German WIKI description'''] | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
==Applet Description== | ==Applet Description== | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | This applet allows the calculation and | + | This applet allows the calculation and graphical display of |
| − | *the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z=\mu)$ of a discrete random variable $z \in \{\mu \} = \{0, 1, 2, 3, \text{...} \}$, that determine its ''Probability Density Function'' (PDF) | + | *the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z=\mu)$ of a discrete random variable $z \in \{\mu \} = \{0, 1, 2, 3, \text{...} \}$, that determine its ''Probability Density Function'' (PDF) – here representation with Dirac delta functions ${\rm \delta}( z-\mu)$: |
:$$f_{z}(z)=\sum_{\mu=1}^{M}{\rm Pr}(z=\mu)\cdot {\rm \delta}( z-\mu),$$ | :$$f_{z}(z)=\sum_{\mu=1}^{M}{\rm Pr}(z=\mu)\cdot {\rm \delta}( z-\mu),$$ | ||
| − | *the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z \le \mu)$ of the Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) | + | *the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z \le \mu)$ of the ''Cumulative Distribution Function'' (CDF): |
| + | :$$F_{z}(\mu)={\rm Pr}(z\le\mu).$$ | ||
| Line 13: | Line 17: | ||
| − | + | In the exercises below you will be able to compare: | |
* two Binomial distributions with different sets of parameters $I$ and $p$, | * two Binomial distributions with different sets of parameters $I$ and $p$, | ||
* two Poisson distributions with different rates $\lambda$, | * two Poisson distributions with different rates $\lambda$, | ||
| Line 19: | Line 23: | ||
==Theoretical Background== | ==Theoretical Background== | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | ===Properties of Binomial Distribution=== | + | ===Properties of the Binomial Distribution=== |
| − | |||
The ''Binomial distribution'' represents an important special case for the likelihood of occurence of a discrete random variable. For the derivation we assume, that $I$ binary and statistically independent random variables $b_i \in \{0, 1 \}$ can take | The ''Binomial distribution'' represents an important special case for the likelihood of occurence of a discrete random variable. For the derivation we assume, that $I$ binary and statistically independent random variables $b_i \in \{0, 1 \}$ can take | ||
*the value $1$ with the probability ${\rm Pr}(b_i = 1) = p$, and | *the value $1$ with the probability ${\rm Pr}(b_i = 1) = p$, and | ||
| Line 27: | Line 30: | ||
| − | + | The sum | |
| − | + | :$$z=\sum_{i=1}^{I}b_i$$ | |
| − | + | is also a discrete random variable with symbols from the set $\{0, 1, 2, \cdots\ , I\}$ with size $M = I + 1$ and is called "binomially distributed". | |
| − | '''Probabilities of | + | '''Probabilities of the Binomial Distribution''' |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | The probabilities to find $z = \mu$ for $μ = 0, \text{...}\ , I$ are given as | |
:$$p_\mu = {\rm Pr}(z=\mu)={I \choose \mu}\cdot p^\mu\cdot ({\rm 1}-p)^{I-\mu},$$ | :$$p_\mu = {\rm Pr}(z=\mu)={I \choose \mu}\cdot p^\mu\cdot ({\rm 1}-p)^{I-\mu},$$ | ||
| − | + | with the number of combinations $(I \text{ over }\mu)$: | |
:$${I \choose \mu}=\frac{I !}{\mu !\cdot (I-\mu) !}=\frac{ {I\cdot (I- 1) \cdot \ \cdots \ \cdot (I-\mu+ 1)} }{ 1\cdot 2\cdot \ \cdots \ \cdot \mu}.$$ | :$${I \choose \mu}=\frac{I !}{\mu !\cdot (I-\mu) !}=\frac{ {I\cdot (I- 1) \cdot \ \cdots \ \cdot (I-\mu+ 1)} }{ 1\cdot 2\cdot \ \cdots \ \cdot \mu}.$$ | ||
| − | |||
| − | + | '''Moments of the Binomial Distribution''' | |
| + | |||
| + | Consider a binomially distributed random variable $z$ and its expected value of order $k$: | ||
:$$m_k={\rm E}[z^k]=\sum_{\mu={\rm 0}}^{I}\mu^k\cdot{I \choose \mu}\cdot p^\mu\cdot ({\rm 1}-p)^{I-\mu}.$$ | :$$m_k={\rm E}[z^k]=\sum_{\mu={\rm 0}}^{I}\mu^k\cdot{I \choose \mu}\cdot p^\mu\cdot ({\rm 1}-p)^{I-\mu}.$$ | ||
| − | + | We can derive the formulas for | |
*the linear average: $m_1 = I\cdot p,$ | *the linear average: $m_1 = I\cdot p,$ | ||
| − | *the | + | *the second moment: $m_2 = (I^2-I)\cdot p^2+I\cdot p,$ |
| − | *the variance and | + | *the variance and standard deviation: $\sigma^2 = {m_2 - m_1^2} = {I \cdot p\cdot (1-p)} \hspace{0.3cm}\Rightarrow \hspace{0.3cm} |
\sigma = \sqrt{I \cdot p\cdot (1-p)}.$ | \sigma = \sqrt{I \cdot p\cdot (1-p)}.$ | ||
| − | '''Applications of Binomial Distribution''' | + | '''Applications of the Binomial Distribution''' |
| − | The Binomial distribution has a variety of uses in telecommunications as well as other disciplines : | + | The Binomial distribution has a variety of uses in telecommunications as well as in other disciplines: |
| − | *It characterizes the distribution of rejected parts (Ausschussstücken) in | + | *It characterizes the distribution of rejected parts (Ausschussstücken) in statistical quality control. |
| − | *The bit error rate of a digital transmission system | + | *The simulated bit error rate of a digital transmission system is technically a binomially distributed random variable. |
| − | *The binomial distribution can be used to calculate the residual error probability with blockwise coding, as the following example shows. | + | *The binomial distribution can be used to calculate the residual error probability with blockwise coding, as the following example shows. |
| Line 63: | Line 67: | ||
$\text{Example 1:}$ | $\text{Example 1:}$ | ||
When transfering blocks of $I =5$ binary symbols through a channel, that | When transfering blocks of $I =5$ binary symbols through a channel, that | ||
| − | *distorts a symbol with probability $p = 0.1$ ⇒ | + | *distorts a symbol with probability $p = 0.1$ ⇒ random variable $e_i = 1$, and |
| − | *transfers the symbol undistorted with probability $1 - p = 0.9$ ⇒ | + | *transfers the symbol undistorted with probability $1 - p = 0.9$ ⇒ random variable $e_i = 0$, |
| − | the new random variable $f$ ( | + | the new random variable $f$ ("error per block") calculates to: |
:$$f=\sum_{i=1}^{I}e_i.$$ | :$$f=\sum_{i=1}^{I}e_i.$$ | ||
| − | $f$ can now | + | $f$ can now take integer values between $\mu = 0$ (all symbols are correct) and $\mu = I = 5$ (all five symbols are erroneous). We describe the probability of $\mu$ errors as $p_μ = {\rm Pr}(f = \mu)$. |
| − | *The case that all five symbols are transmitted correctly occurs with the probability of $p_0 = 0.9^{5} ≈ 0.5905$. This also be | + | *The case that all five symbols are transmitted correctly occurs with the probability of $p_0 = 0.9^{5} ≈ 0.5905$. This can also be seen from the binomial formula for $μ = 0$ , considering the definition $5\text{ over } 0 = 1$. |
| − | *A | + | *A single error $(f = 1)$ occurs with the probability $p_1 = 5\cdot 0.1\cdot 0.9^4\approx 0.3281$. The first factor indicates, that there are $5\text{ over } 1 = 5$ possibe error positions. The other two factors take into account, that one symbol was erroneous and the other four are correct when $f =1$. |
| − | *For $f =2$ there are $5\text{ | + | *For $f =2$ there are $5\text{ over } 2 = (5 \cdot 4)/(1 \cdot 2) = 10$ combinations and you get a probability of $p_2 = 10\cdot 0.1^2\cdot 0.9^3\approx 0.0729$. |
| − | If a block code can correct up to two errors, | + | If a block code can correct up to two errors, the residual error probability is $p_{\rm R} = 1-p_{\rm 0}-p_{\rm 1}-p_{\rm 2}\approx 0.85\%$. |
A second calculation option would be $p_{\rm R} = p_{3} + p_{4} + p_{5}$ with the approximation $p_{\rm R} \approx p_{3} = 0.81\%.$ | A second calculation option would be $p_{\rm R} = p_{3} + p_{4} + p_{5}$ with the approximation $p_{\rm R} \approx p_{3} = 0.81\%.$ | ||
| − | The | + | The average number of errors in a block is $m_f = 5 \cdot 0.1 = 0.5$ and the variance of the random variable $f$ is $\sigma_f^2 = 5 \cdot 0.1 \cdot 0.9= 0.45$ ⇒ standard deviation $\sigma_f \approx 0.671.$}} |
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | ===Properties of the Poisson Distribution=== | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
The ''Poisson distribution'' is a special case of the Binomial distribution, where | The ''Poisson distribution'' is a special case of the Binomial distribution, where | ||
| − | * | + | * $I → \infty$ and $p →0$. |
| − | *Additionally, the | + | *Additionally, the parameter $λ = I · p$ must be finite. |
| − | The parameter $λ$ indicates the average number of "ones" in a specified time unit and is called | + | The parameter $λ$ indicates the average number of "ones" in a specified time unit and is called ''rate''. |
| − | Unlike | + | Unlike the Binomial distribution where $0 ≤ μ ≤ I$, here, the random variable can assume arbitrarily large non-negative integers, which means that the number of possible values is not countable. However, since no intermediate values can occur, the Poisson distribution is still a "discrete distribution". |
| − | '''Probabilities of Poisson Distribution''' | + | '''Probabilities of the Poisson Distribution''' |
| − | + | With the limits $I → \infty$ and $p →0$, the likelihood of occurence of the Poisson distributed random variable $z$ can be derived from the probabilities of the Binomial distribution: | |
:$$p_\mu = {\rm Pr} ( z=\mu ) = \lim_{I\to\infty} \cdot \frac{I !}{\mu ! \cdot (I-\mu )!} \cdot (\frac{\lambda}{I} )^\mu \cdot ( 1-\frac{\lambda}{I})^{I-\mu}.$$ | :$$p_\mu = {\rm Pr} ( z=\mu ) = \lim_{I\to\infty} \cdot \frac{I !}{\mu ! \cdot (I-\mu )!} \cdot (\frac{\lambda}{I} )^\mu \cdot ( 1-\frac{\lambda}{I})^{I-\mu}.$$ | ||
| − | After some algebraic transformations we obtain | + | After some algebraic transformations we finally obtain |
:$$p_\mu = \frac{ \lambda^\mu}{\mu!}\cdot {\rm e}^{-\lambda}.$$ | :$$p_\mu = \frac{ \lambda^\mu}{\mu!}\cdot {\rm e}^{-\lambda}.$$ | ||
| + | '''Moments of the Poisson Distribution''' | ||
| − | + | The moments of the Poisson distribution can be derived directly from the corresponding equations of the Binomial distribution by taking the limits again: | |
| − | + | :$$m_1 =\lim_{\left.{I\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm}\infty, \hspace{0.2cm} {p\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm} 0}}\right.} \hspace{0.2cm} I \cdot p= \lambda,\hspace{0.8cm} | |
| − | + | \sigma =\lim_{\left.{I\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm}\infty, \hspace{0.2cm} {p\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm} 0}}\right.} \hspace{0.2cm} \sqrt{I \cdot p \cdot (1-p)} = \sqrt {\lambda}.$$ | |
| − | :$$m_1 =\lim_{\left.{I\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm}\infty \ | ||
| − | |||
| − | We can see that | + | We can see that for the Poisson distribution $\sigma^2 = m_1 = \lambda$ always holds. In contrast, the moments of the Binomial distribution always fulfill $\sigma^2 < m_1$. |
| − | [[File: P_ID616__Sto_T_2_4_S2neu.png |frame| Moments of Poisson Distribution | + | [[File: P_ID616__Sto_T_2_4_S2neu.png |frame| Moments of Poisson Distribution]] |
{{GraueBox|TEXT= | {{GraueBox|TEXT= | ||
$\text{Example 2:}$ | $\text{Example 2:}$ | ||
| − | We now compare | + | We now compare the Binomial distribution with parameters $I =6$ und $p = 0.4$ with the Poisson distribution with $λ = 2.4$: |
| − | |||
| − | |||
*Both distributions have the same linear average $m_1 = 2.4$. | *Both distributions have the same linear average $m_1 = 2.4$. | ||
| − | *The | + | *The standard deviation of the Poisson distribution (marked red in the figure) is $σ ≈ 1.55$. |
| − | *The standard deviation of the Binomial distribution (marked blue) is $σ = 1.2$.}} | + | *The standard deviation of the Binomial distribution (marked blue) is $σ = 1.2$. |
| + | }} | ||
| − | '''Applications of Poisson Distribution''' | + | '''Applications of the Poisson Distribution''' |
The Poisson distribution is the result of a so-called ''Poisson point process'' which is often used as a model for a series of events that may occur at random times. Examples of such events are | The Poisson distribution is the result of a so-called ''Poisson point process'' which is often used as a model for a series of events that may occur at random times. Examples of such events are | ||
| − | * | + | * failure of devices - an important task in reliability theory, |
| − | * | + | * shot noise in the optical transmission simulations, and |
| − | *the start of conversations | + | * the start of conversations in a telephone relay center („Teletraffic engineering”). |
{{GraueBox|TEXT= | {{GraueBox|TEXT= | ||
$\text{Example 3:}$ | $\text{Example 3:}$ | ||
| − | A telephone | + | A telephone relay receives ninety requests per minute on average $(λ = 1.5 \text{ per second})$. The probabilities $p_µ$, that in an arbitrarily large time frame exactly $\mu$ requests are received, is: |
:$$p_\mu = \frac{1.5^\mu}{\mu!}\cdot {\rm e}^{-1.5}.$$ | :$$p_\mu = \frac{1.5^\mu}{\mu!}\cdot {\rm e}^{-1.5}.$$ | ||
| Line 136: | Line 139: | ||
From this, additional parameters can be derived: | From this, additional parameters can be derived: | ||
| − | * | + | * The distance $τ$ between two requests satisfies the "exponential distribution", |
| − | *The mean time span between two requests is ${\rm E}[τ] = 1/λ ≈ 0.667 \ \rm s$.}} | + | * The mean time span between two requests is ${\rm E}[τ] = 1/λ ≈ 0.667 \ \rm s$. |
| + | }} | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | [[File: | + | === Comparison of Binomial and Poisson Distribution === |
| − | The '''Binomial distribution''' is used to describe stochastic events, that have a fixed period $T$. For example the period of an ISDN (''Integrated Services Digital Network'') with $64 \ \rm kbit/s$ is $T \approx 15.6 \ \rm | + | This section deals with the similarities and differences between Binomial and Poisson distributions. |
| − | *Binary events such as the error-free $(e_i = 0)$/ faulty $(e_i = 1)$ transmission of individual symbols only occur in this time frame. | + | |
| − | * | + | [[File: EN_Sto_T_2_4_S3.png |frame| Binomial vs. Poisson distribution]] |
| − | *For very large values of $I$ the Binomial distribution can be approximated by the ''Poisson distribution''. | + | |
| − | * | + | The '''Binomial distribution''' is used to describe stochastic events, that have a fixed period $T$. For example the period of an ISDN (''Integrated Services Digital Network'') network with $64 \ \rm kbit/s$ is $T \approx 15.6 \ \rm \mu s$. |
| + | * Binary events such as the error-free $(e_i = 0)$/ faulty $(e_i = 1)$ transmission of individual symbols only occur in this time frame. | ||
| + | * With the Binomial distribution, it is possible to make statistical statements about the number of expected erros in a period $T_{\rm I} = I · T$, as is shown in the time figure above (marked blue). | ||
| + | * For very large values of $I$ and very small values of $p$, the Binomial distribution can be approximated by the ''Poisson distribution'' with rate $\lambda = I \cdot p$. | ||
| + | * If at the same time $I · p \gg 1$, the Poisson distribution as well as the Binomial distribution turn into a discrete Gaussian distribution according to the ''de Moivre-Laplace Theorem''. | ||
The '''Poisson distribution''' can also be used to make statements about the number of occuring binary events in a finite time interval. | The '''Poisson distribution''' can also be used to make statements about the number of occuring binary events in a finite time interval. | ||
| − | By assuming the same observation period $T_{\rm I}$ and increasing the number of partial periods $I$, the period $T$, in which a new event ($0$ or $1$) can occur, gets smaller and smaller. In the | + | By assuming the same observation period $T_{\rm I}$ and increasing the number of partial periods $I$, the period $T$, in which a new event ($0$ or $1$) can occur, gets smaller and smaller. In the limit where $T$ goes to zero, this means: |
| − | *With the Poisson distribution binary events can not only occur at certain given times, but at any time, which is illustrated in the time chart | + | * With the Poisson distribution binary events can not only occur at certain given times, but at any time, which is illustrated in the second time chart. |
| − | *In order to | + | * In order to get the same number of "ones" in the period $T_{\rm I}$ - in average - as in the Binomial distribution (six pulses in the example), the characteristic probability $p = {\rm Pr}( e_i = 1)$ for an infinitesimal small time interval $T$ must go to zero. |
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | + | ==Exercises== | |
| − | * | + | * First select the number $(1,\text{...}, 7)$ of the exercise. The number $0$ corresponds to a "Reset": Same setting as at program start. |
| + | *A task description is displayed. The parameter values are adjusted. Solution after pressing "Show solution". <br> | ||
| + | *In these exercises, the term '''Blue''' refers to distribution function 1 (marked blue in the applet) and the term '''Red''' refers to distribution function 2 (marked red in applet). | ||
{{BlaueBox|TEXT= | {{BlaueBox|TEXT= | ||
| − | '''(1)''' | + | '''(1)''' Set '''Blue''' to Binomial distribution $(I=5, \ p=0.4)$ and '''Red''' to Binomial distribution $(I=10, \ p=0.2)$. |
| − | : | + | :What are the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z=0)$ and ${\rm Pr}(z=1)$? |
| + | }} | ||
| − | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Blue: }{\rm Pr}(z=0)=0.6^5=7.78\%, \hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z=1)=0.4 \cdot 0.6^4=25.92\%;$ |
| − | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Red: }{\rm Pr}(z=0)=0.8^{10}=10.74\%, \hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z=1)=0.2 \cdot 0.8^9=26.84\%.$ |
{{BlaueBox|TEXT= | {{BlaueBox|TEXT= | ||
| − | '''(2)''' | + | '''(2)''' Using the same settings as in '''(1)''', what are the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5)$? |
| + | }} | ||
| − | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Note that }{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = {\rm Pr}(z=3) + {\rm Pr}(z=4) + {\rm Pr}(z=5)\text{, or } |
{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = {\rm Pr}(z \le 5) - {\rm Pr}(z \le 2)$ | {\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = {\rm Pr}(z \le 5) - {\rm Pr}(z \le 2)$ | ||
| − | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Blue: }{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = 0.2304+ 0.0768 + 0.0102 =1 - 0.6826 = 0.3174;$ |
| − | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Red: }{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = 0.2013 + 0.0881 + 0.0264 = 0.9936 - 0.6778 = 0.3158.$ |
{{BlaueBox|TEXT= | {{BlaueBox|TEXT= | ||
| − | '''(3)''' | + | '''(3)''' Using the same settings as in '''(1)''', what are the differences in the linear average $m_1$ and the standard deviation $\sigma$ between the two Binomial distributions? |
| + | }} | ||
| − | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Average:}\hspace{0.2cm}m_\text{1} = I \cdot p\hspace{0.3cm} \Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} m_\text{1, Blue} = 5 \cdot 0.4\underline{ = 2 =} \ m_\text{1, Red} = 10 \cdot 0.2; $ |
| − | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Standard deviation:}\hspace{0.4cm}\sigma = \sqrt{I \cdot p \cdot (1-p)} = \sqrt{m_1 \cdot (1-p)}\hspace{0.3cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \sigma_{\rm Blue} = \sqrt{2 \cdot 0.6} =1.095 < \sigma_{\rm Red} = \sqrt{2 \cdot 0.8} = 1.265.$ |
{{BlaueBox|TEXT= | {{BlaueBox|TEXT= | ||
| − | '''(4)''' | + | '''(4)''' Set '''Blue''' to Binomial distribution $(I=15, p=0.3)$ and '''Red''' to Poisson distribution $(\lambda=4.5)$. |
| − | : | + | :What differences arise between both distributions regarding the average $m_1$ and variance $\sigma^2$? |
| + | }} | ||
| − | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{ | + | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Both distributions have the same average:}\hspace{0.2cm}m_\text{1, Blue} = I \cdot p\ = 15 \cdot 0.3\hspace{0.15cm}\underline{ = 4.5 =} \ m_\text{1, Red} = \lambda$; |
| − | $\hspace{1.85cm} \text{ | + | $\hspace{1.85cm} \text{Binomial distribution: }\hspace{0.2cm} \sigma_\text{Blue}^2 = m_\text{1, Blue} \cdot (1-p)\hspace{0.15cm}\underline { = 3.15} < \text{Poisson distribution: }\hspace{0.2cm} \sigma_\text{Red}^2 = \lambda\hspace{0.15cm}\underline { = 4.5}$; |
{{BlaueBox|TEXT= | {{BlaueBox|TEXT= | ||
| − | '''(5)''' | + | '''(5)''' Using the same settings as in '''(4)''', what are the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z \gt 10)$ and ${\rm Pr}(z \gt 15)$? |
| + | }} | ||
| − | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \text{Binomial: }\hspace{0.2cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 10) = 1 - {\rm Pr}(z \le 10) = 1 - 0.9993 = 0.0007;\hspace{0.3cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) = 0$. | + | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \text{Binomial: }\hspace{0.2cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 10) = 1 - {\rm Pr}(z \le 10) = 1 - 0.9993 = 0.0007;\hspace{0.3cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) = 0 \ {\rm (exactly)}$. |
| − | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Poisson: }\hspace{0.2cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 10) = 1 - 0.9933 = 0.0067;\hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) \gt 0\hspace{0. | + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Poisson: }\hspace{0.2cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 10) = 1 - 0.9933 = 0.0067;\hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) \gt 0\hspace{0.2cm}( \approx 0)$; |
| + | |||
| + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Approximation: }\hspace{0.2cm}{\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) \ge {\rm Pr}(z = 16) = \lambda^{16} /{16!}\approx 2 \cdot 10^{-22}$ | ||
{{BlaueBox|TEXT= | {{BlaueBox|TEXT= | ||
| − | '''(6)''' | + | '''(6)''' Using the same settings as in '''(4)''', which parameters lead to a symmetric distribution around $m_1$? |
| + | }} | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | $\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \text{Binomial distribution with }p = 0.5\text{: }p_\mu = {\rm Pr}(z = \mu)\text{ symmetric around } m_1 = I/2 = 7.5 \ ⇒ \ p_μ = p_{I–μ}\ ⇒ \ p_8 = p_7, \ p_9 = p_6, \text{etc.}$ | ||
| + | |||
| + | $\hspace{1.85cm}\text{In contrast, the Poisson distribution is never symmetric, since it extends to infinity!}$ | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | ==Applet Manual== | ||
| + | [[File:Handhabung_binomial.png|left|600px]] | ||
| + | '''(A)''' Preselection for blue parameter set | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(B)''' Parameter input: Sliders $I$ and $p$ | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(C)''' Preselection for Red parameter set | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(D)''' Parameter input: Slider $\lambda$ | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(E)''' Graphic display of the Distribution | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(F)''' Output of moments for blue parameter set | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(G)''' Output of moments for redparameter set | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''(H)''' Variation possibilities for the graphic display | ||
| + | |||
| + | $\hspace{1.5cm}$"$+$" (Zoom in), | ||
| + | |||
| + | $\hspace{1.5cm}$ "$-$" (Zoom out) | ||
| + | $\hspace{1.5cm}$ "$\rm o$" (Reset) | ||
| − | $\hspace{1. | + | $\hspace{1.5cm}$ "$\leftarrow$" (Move left), etc. |
| − | $\ | + | '''( I )''' Output of ${\rm Pr} (z = \mu)$ and ${\rm Pr} (z \le \mu)$ |
| + | '''(J)''' Exercises: Exercise selection, description and solution | ||
| + | <br clear=all> | ||
| + | <br>'''Other options for graphic display''': | ||
| + | *Hold shift and scroll: Zoom in on/out of coordinate system, | ||
| + | *Hold shift and left click: Move the coordinate system. | ||
| − | == | + | ==About the Authors== |
| − | + | This interactive calculation was designed and realized at the [http://www.lnt.ei.tum.de/startseite Lehrstuhl für Nachrichtentechnik] of the [https://www.tum.de/ Technische Universität München]. | |
| − | * | + | *The original version was created in 2003 by [[Biographies_and_Bibliographies/An_LNTwww_beteiligte_Studierende#Ji_Li_.28Bachelorarbeit_EI_2003.2C_Diplomarbeit_EI_2005.29|Ji Li]] as part of her Diploma thesis using "FlashMX–Actionscript" (Supervisor: [[Biographies_and_Bibliographies/An_LNTwww_beteiligte_Mitarbeiter_und_Dozenten#Prof._Dr.-Ing._habil._G.C3.BCnter_S.C3.B6der_.28am_LNT_seit_1974.29|Günter Söder]]). |
| − | *2018 | + | *In 2018 this Applet was redesigned and updated to "HTML5" by [[Biographies_and_Bibliographies/An_LNTwww_beteiligte_Studierende#Jimmy_He_.28Bachelorarbeit_2018.29|Jimmy He]] as part of his Bachelor's thesis (Supervisor: [[Biographies_and_Bibliographies/Beteiligte_der_Professur_Leitungsgebundene_%C3%9Cbertragungstechnik#Tasn.C3.A1d_Kernetzky.2C_M.Sc._.28bei_L.C3.9CT_seit_2014.29|Tasnád Kernetzky]]) . |
| − | == | + | ==Once again: Open Applet in new Tab== |
| − | {{ | + | {{LntAppletLinkEn|binomPoissonDistributions_en}} [https://www.lntwww.de/Applets:Binomial-_und_Poissonverteilung_(Applet) '''English Applet with German WIKI description'''] |
Latest revision as of 21:40, 26 March 2023
Open Applet in new Tab English Applet with German WIKI description
Contents
Applet Description
This applet allows the calculation and graphical display of
- the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z=\mu)$ of a discrete random variable $z \in \{\mu \} = \{0, 1, 2, 3, \text{...} \}$, that determine its Probability Density Function (PDF) – here representation with Dirac delta functions ${\rm \delta}( z-\mu)$:
- $$f_{z}(z)=\sum_{\mu=1}^{M}{\rm Pr}(z=\mu)\cdot {\rm \delta}( z-\mu),$$
- the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z \le \mu)$ of the Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF):
- $$F_{z}(\mu)={\rm Pr}(z\le\mu).$$
Discrete distributions are available in two sets of parameters:
- the Binomial distribution with the parameters $I$ and $p$ ⇒ $z \in \{0, 1, \text{...} \ , I \}$ ⇒ $M = I+1$ possible values,
- the Poisson distribution with the parameter $\lambda$ ⇒ $z \in \{0, 1, 2, 3, \text{...}\}$ ⇒ $M \to \infty$.
In the exercises below you will be able to compare:
- two Binomial distributions with different sets of parameters $I$ and $p$,
- two Poisson distributions with different rates $\lambda$,
- a Binomial distribution with a Poisson distribution.
Theoretical Background
Properties of the Binomial Distribution
The Binomial distribution represents an important special case for the likelihood of occurence of a discrete random variable. For the derivation we assume, that $I$ binary and statistically independent random variables $b_i \in \{0, 1 \}$ can take
- the value $1$ with the probability ${\rm Pr}(b_i = 1) = p$, and
- the value $0$ with the probability ${\rm Pr}(b_i = 0) = 1-p$.
The sum
- $$z=\sum_{i=1}^{I}b_i$$
is also a discrete random variable with symbols from the set $\{0, 1, 2, \cdots\ , I\}$ with size $M = I + 1$ and is called "binomially distributed".
Probabilities of the Binomial Distribution
The probabilities to find $z = \mu$ for $μ = 0, \text{...}\ , I$ are given as
- $$p_\mu = {\rm Pr}(z=\mu)={I \choose \mu}\cdot p^\mu\cdot ({\rm 1}-p)^{I-\mu},$$
with the number of combinations $(I \text{ over }\mu)$:
- $${I \choose \mu}=\frac{I !}{\mu !\cdot (I-\mu) !}=\frac{ {I\cdot (I- 1) \cdot \ \cdots \ \cdot (I-\mu+ 1)} }{ 1\cdot 2\cdot \ \cdots \ \cdot \mu}.$$
Moments of the Binomial Distribution
Consider a binomially distributed random variable $z$ and its expected value of order $k$:
- $$m_k={\rm E}[z^k]=\sum_{\mu={\rm 0}}^{I}\mu^k\cdot{I \choose \mu}\cdot p^\mu\cdot ({\rm 1}-p)^{I-\mu}.$$
We can derive the formulas for
- the linear average: $m_1 = I\cdot p,$
- the second moment: $m_2 = (I^2-I)\cdot p^2+I\cdot p,$
- the variance and standard deviation: $\sigma^2 = {m_2 - m_1^2} = {I \cdot p\cdot (1-p)} \hspace{0.3cm}\Rightarrow \hspace{0.3cm} \sigma = \sqrt{I \cdot p\cdot (1-p)}.$
Applications of the Binomial Distribution
The Binomial distribution has a variety of uses in telecommunications as well as in other disciplines:
- It characterizes the distribution of rejected parts (Ausschussstücken) in statistical quality control.
- The simulated bit error rate of a digital transmission system is technically a binomially distributed random variable.
- The binomial distribution can be used to calculate the residual error probability with blockwise coding, as the following example shows.
$\text{Example 1:}$ When transfering blocks of $I =5$ binary symbols through a channel, that
- distorts a symbol with probability $p = 0.1$ ⇒ random variable $e_i = 1$, and
- transfers the symbol undistorted with probability $1 - p = 0.9$ ⇒ random variable $e_i = 0$,
the new random variable $f$ ("error per block") calculates to:
- $$f=\sum_{i=1}^{I}e_i.$$
$f$ can now take integer values between $\mu = 0$ (all symbols are correct) and $\mu = I = 5$ (all five symbols are erroneous). We describe the probability of $\mu$ errors as $p_μ = {\rm Pr}(f = \mu)$.
- The case that all five symbols are transmitted correctly occurs with the probability of $p_0 = 0.9^{5} ≈ 0.5905$. This can also be seen from the binomial formula for $μ = 0$ , considering the definition $5\text{ over } 0 = 1$.
- A single error $(f = 1)$ occurs with the probability $p_1 = 5\cdot 0.1\cdot 0.9^4\approx 0.3281$. The first factor indicates, that there are $5\text{ over } 1 = 5$ possibe error positions. The other two factors take into account, that one symbol was erroneous and the other four are correct when $f =1$.
- For $f =2$ there are $5\text{ over } 2 = (5 \cdot 4)/(1 \cdot 2) = 10$ combinations and you get a probability of $p_2 = 10\cdot 0.1^2\cdot 0.9^3\approx 0.0729$.
If a block code can correct up to two errors, the residual error probability is $p_{\rm R} = 1-p_{\rm 0}-p_{\rm 1}-p_{\rm 2}\approx 0.85\%$.
A second calculation option would be $p_{\rm R} = p_{3} + p_{4} + p_{5}$ with the approximation $p_{\rm R} \approx p_{3} = 0.81\%.$
The average number of errors in a block is $m_f = 5 \cdot 0.1 = 0.5$ and the variance of the random variable $f$ is $\sigma_f^2 = 5 \cdot 0.1 \cdot 0.9= 0.45$ ⇒ standard deviation $\sigma_f \approx 0.671.$
Properties of the Poisson Distribution
The Poisson distribution is a special case of the Binomial distribution, where
- $I → \infty$ and $p →0$.
- Additionally, the parameter $λ = I · p$ must be finite.
The parameter $λ$ indicates the average number of "ones" in a specified time unit and is called rate.
Unlike the Binomial distribution where $0 ≤ μ ≤ I$, here, the random variable can assume arbitrarily large non-negative integers, which means that the number of possible values is not countable. However, since no intermediate values can occur, the Poisson distribution is still a "discrete distribution".
Probabilities of the Poisson Distribution
With the limits $I → \infty$ and $p →0$, the likelihood of occurence of the Poisson distributed random variable $z$ can be derived from the probabilities of the Binomial distribution:
- $$p_\mu = {\rm Pr} ( z=\mu ) = \lim_{I\to\infty} \cdot \frac{I !}{\mu ! \cdot (I-\mu )!} \cdot (\frac{\lambda}{I} )^\mu \cdot ( 1-\frac{\lambda}{I})^{I-\mu}.$$
After some algebraic transformations we finally obtain
- $$p_\mu = \frac{ \lambda^\mu}{\mu!}\cdot {\rm e}^{-\lambda}.$$
Moments of the Poisson Distribution
The moments of the Poisson distribution can be derived directly from the corresponding equations of the Binomial distribution by taking the limits again:
- $$m_1 =\lim_{\left.{I\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm}\infty, \hspace{0.2cm} {p\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm} 0}}\right.} \hspace{0.2cm} I \cdot p= \lambda,\hspace{0.8cm} \sigma =\lim_{\left.{I\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm}\infty, \hspace{0.2cm} {p\hspace{0.05cm}\to\hspace{0.05cm} 0}}\right.} \hspace{0.2cm} \sqrt{I \cdot p \cdot (1-p)} = \sqrt {\lambda}.$$
We can see that for the Poisson distribution $\sigma^2 = m_1 = \lambda$ always holds. In contrast, the moments of the Binomial distribution always fulfill $\sigma^2 < m_1$.
Moments of Poisson Distribution
$\text{Example 2:}$ We now compare the Binomial distribution with parameters $I =6$ und $p = 0.4$ with the Poisson distribution with $λ = 2.4$:
- Both distributions have the same linear average $m_1 = 2.4$.
- The standard deviation of the Poisson distribution (marked red in the figure) is $σ ≈ 1.55$.
- The standard deviation of the Binomial distribution (marked blue) is $σ = 1.2$.
Applications of the Poisson Distribution
The Poisson distribution is the result of a so-called Poisson point process which is often used as a model for a series of events that may occur at random times. Examples of such events are
- failure of devices - an important task in reliability theory,
- shot noise in the optical transmission simulations, and
- the start of conversations in a telephone relay center („Teletraffic engineering”).
$\text{Example 3:}$ A telephone relay receives ninety requests per minute on average $(λ = 1.5 \text{ per second})$. The probabilities $p_µ$, that in an arbitrarily large time frame exactly $\mu$ requests are received, is:
- $$p_\mu = \frac{1.5^\mu}{\mu!}\cdot {\rm e}^{-1.5}.$$
The resulting numerical values are $p_0 = 0.223$, $p_1 = 0.335$, $p_2 = 0.251$, etc.
From this, additional parameters can be derived:
- The distance $τ$ between two requests satisfies the "exponential distribution",
- The mean time span between two requests is ${\rm E}[τ] = 1/λ ≈ 0.667 \ \rm s$.
Comparison of Binomial and Poisson Distribution
This section deals with the similarities and differences between Binomial and Poisson distributions.
Binomial vs. Poisson distribution
The Binomial distribution is used to describe stochastic events, that have a fixed period $T$. For example the period of an ISDN (Integrated Services Digital Network) network with $64 \ \rm kbit/s$ is $T \approx 15.6 \ \rm \mu s$.
- Binary events such as the error-free $(e_i = 0)$/ faulty $(e_i = 1)$ transmission of individual symbols only occur in this time frame.
- With the Binomial distribution, it is possible to make statistical statements about the number of expected erros in a period $T_{\rm I} = I · T$, as is shown in the time figure above (marked blue).
- For very large values of $I$ and very small values of $p$, the Binomial distribution can be approximated by the Poisson distribution with rate $\lambda = I \cdot p$.
- If at the same time $I · p \gg 1$, the Poisson distribution as well as the Binomial distribution turn into a discrete Gaussian distribution according to the de Moivre-Laplace Theorem.
The Poisson distribution can also be used to make statements about the number of occuring binary events in a finite time interval.
By assuming the same observation period $T_{\rm I}$ and increasing the number of partial periods $I$, the period $T$, in which a new event ($0$ or $1$) can occur, gets smaller and smaller. In the limit where $T$ goes to zero, this means:
- With the Poisson distribution binary events can not only occur at certain given times, but at any time, which is illustrated in the second time chart.
- In order to get the same number of "ones" in the period $T_{\rm I}$ - in average - as in the Binomial distribution (six pulses in the example), the characteristic probability $p = {\rm Pr}( e_i = 1)$ for an infinitesimal small time interval $T$ must go to zero.
Exercises
- First select the number $(1,\text{...}, 7)$ of the exercise. The number $0$ corresponds to a "Reset": Same setting as at program start.
- A task description is displayed. The parameter values are adjusted. Solution after pressing "Show solution".
- In these exercises, the term Blue refers to distribution function 1 (marked blue in the applet) and the term Red refers to distribution function 2 (marked red in applet).
(1) Set Blue to Binomial distribution $(I=5, \ p=0.4)$ and Red to Binomial distribution $(I=10, \ p=0.2)$.
- What are the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z=0)$ and ${\rm Pr}(z=1)$?
$\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Blue: }{\rm Pr}(z=0)=0.6^5=7.78\%, \hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z=1)=0.4 \cdot 0.6^4=25.92\%;$
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Red: }{\rm Pr}(z=0)=0.8^{10}=10.74\%, \hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z=1)=0.2 \cdot 0.8^9=26.84\%.$
(2) Using the same settings as in (1), what are the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5)$?
$\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Note that }{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = {\rm Pr}(z=3) + {\rm Pr}(z=4) + {\rm Pr}(z=5)\text{, or }
{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = {\rm Pr}(z \le 5) - {\rm Pr}(z \le 2)$
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Blue: }{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = 0.2304+ 0.0768 + 0.0102 =1 - 0.6826 = 0.3174;$
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Red: }{\rm Pr}(3 \le z \le 5) = 0.2013 + 0.0881 + 0.0264 = 0.9936 - 0.6778 = 0.3158.$
(3) Using the same settings as in (1), what are the differences in the linear average $m_1$ and the standard deviation $\sigma$ between the two Binomial distributions?
$\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Average:}\hspace{0.2cm}m_\text{1} = I \cdot p\hspace{0.3cm} \Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} m_\text{1, Blue} = 5 \cdot 0.4\underline{ = 2 =} \ m_\text{1, Red} = 10 \cdot 0.2; $
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Standard deviation:}\hspace{0.4cm}\sigma = \sqrt{I \cdot p \cdot (1-p)} = \sqrt{m_1 \cdot (1-p)}\hspace{0.3cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \sigma_{\rm Blue} = \sqrt{2 \cdot 0.6} =1.095 < \sigma_{\rm Red} = \sqrt{2 \cdot 0.8} = 1.265.$
(4) Set Blue to Binomial distribution $(I=15, p=0.3)$ and Red to Poisson distribution $(\lambda=4.5)$.
- What differences arise between both distributions regarding the average $m_1$ and variance $\sigma^2$?
$\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm}\text{Both distributions have the same average:}\hspace{0.2cm}m_\text{1, Blue} = I \cdot p\ = 15 \cdot 0.3\hspace{0.15cm}\underline{ = 4.5 =} \ m_\text{1, Red} = \lambda$;
$\hspace{1.85cm} \text{Binomial distribution: }\hspace{0.2cm} \sigma_\text{Blue}^2 = m_\text{1, Blue} \cdot (1-p)\hspace{0.15cm}\underline { = 3.15} < \text{Poisson distribution: }\hspace{0.2cm} \sigma_\text{Red}^2 = \lambda\hspace{0.15cm}\underline { = 4.5}$;
(5) Using the same settings as in (4), what are the probabilities ${\rm Pr}(z \gt 10)$ and ${\rm Pr}(z \gt 15)$?
$\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \text{Binomial: }\hspace{0.2cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 10) = 1 - {\rm Pr}(z \le 10) = 1 - 0.9993 = 0.0007;\hspace{0.3cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) = 0 \ {\rm (exactly)}$.
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Poisson: }\hspace{0.2cm} {\rm Pr}(z \gt 10) = 1 - 0.9933 = 0.0067;\hspace{0.3cm}{\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) \gt 0\hspace{0.2cm}( \approx 0)$;
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{Approximation: }\hspace{0.2cm}{\rm Pr}(z \gt 15) \ge {\rm Pr}(z = 16) = \lambda^{16} /{16!}\approx 2 \cdot 10^{-22}$
(6) Using the same settings as in (4), which parameters lead to a symmetric distribution around $m_1$?
$\hspace{1.0cm}\Rightarrow\hspace{0.3cm} \text{Binomial distribution with }p = 0.5\text{: }p_\mu = {\rm Pr}(z = \mu)\text{ symmetric around } m_1 = I/2 = 7.5 \ ⇒ \ p_μ = p_{I–μ}\ ⇒ \ p_8 = p_7, \ p_9 = p_6, \text{etc.}$
$\hspace{1.85cm}\text{In contrast, the Poisson distribution is never symmetric, since it extends to infinity!}$
Applet Manual
(A) Preselection for blue parameter set
(B) Parameter input: Sliders $I$ and $p$
(C) Preselection for Red parameter set
(D) Parameter input: Slider $\lambda$
(E) Graphic display of the Distribution
(F) Output of moments for blue parameter set
(G) Output of moments for redparameter set
(H) Variation possibilities for the graphic display
$\hspace{1.5cm}$"$+$" (Zoom in),
$\hspace{1.5cm}$ "$-$" (Zoom out)
$\hspace{1.5cm}$ "$\rm o$" (Reset)
$\hspace{1.5cm}$ "$\leftarrow$" (Move left), etc.
( I ) Output of ${\rm Pr} (z = \mu)$ and ${\rm Pr} (z \le \mu)$
(J) Exercises: Exercise selection, description and solution
Other options for graphic display:
- Hold shift and scroll: Zoom in on/out of coordinate system,
- Hold shift and left click: Move the coordinate system.
About the Authors
This interactive calculation was designed and realized at the Lehrstuhl für Nachrichtentechnik of the Technische Universität München.
- The original version was created in 2003 by Ji Li as part of her Diploma thesis using "FlashMX–Actionscript" (Supervisor: Günter Söder).
- In 2018 this Applet was redesigned and updated to "HTML5" by Jimmy He as part of his Bachelor's thesis (Supervisor: Tasnád Kernetzky) .
Once again: Open Applet in new Tab
Open Applet in new Tab English Applet with German WIKI description
